Skip to main content

Audio/Video Podcasts: Pros and Cons for Adult Learners


Podcasts are digital audio files that can be used to facilitate learning. Videos provide the visual component to accompany the audio information.Both forms of technology can be useful for instructors to facilitate instruction and/or creating engaging student assignments using the technology. Following are some pros and cons to consider when including technology for either of these purposes:

  • Pros:
    • Portable and can be globally shared, meaning we can "cultivate the means to building and sustaining global scholarship communities" (King & Cox, 2011, p. 34). 
    • Technology is simple and inexpensive
    • Ability to build assignments that "generate deeper research, analysis, and knowledge construction" (King & Cox, 2011, p. 34)
    • Connect creativity to content
    • Instructors can record lectures and turn them into podcasts or videos so students who had to miss the lecture can still have an opportunity to hear it
    • Instructors can slice lectures into smaller sections that focus on difficult concepts. In this way students can review the material to get a better understanding of critical concepts. 
    • Instructors can record Q&A sessions so that future students can benefit from the answers. In addition instructors don't have to answer the same questions repeatedly for each new class
    • Instructors can use podcasts or videos to supplement instruction so that students can be exposed to different instructors and forms of instruction (e.g. interviews, book reviews)
    • Instructors can create tutorials to dive deep into difficult concepts in the curriculum to provide instructional support.

  • Cons
    • An audio or video device is required, as well as an internet connection and a host site for the podcast or video
    • Notetaking can be difficult, and listeners can't highlight certain information they want to revisit
    • Recorded lectures just provide a review of the material covered, rather than providing the material in a different or novel way to further understanding
    • Instructors mainly use podcasts and videos as full lecture recordings and fail to use them in more innovative, effective ways to promote learning
    • Podcasts and videos are housed on the internet and open to the public
    • Instructors that assign podcasts or videos for grades have to take the time to listen and/or view every student's submission and create a rubric for grading
One particular consideration for smaller schools is the amount of support for technology. Due to limited resources, smaller schools may have to outsource technology support, which means it's not readily available onsite (Anderson, et al.,  2019). One benefit for small schools is that decisions can be made quickly, so it may be easier to incorporate technology into curriculum when an instructor chooses to do so (Anderson, et al., 2019).
Overall video and audio podcasts can be effective tools for instructors and students, particularly for online learning formats. Instructors can be aware of potential pitfalls and avoid them to make the best use of technology to support their instruction.

References:
Anderson, B., Brassard, K., & Thomas, C. (2019). Little college, big world: Big tech wins for small schools [podcast]. https://er.educause.edu/multimedia/2019/4/little-college-big-world-big-tech-wins-for-small-schools
King, K.P. & Cox, T.D. (2011). The Professor's Guide to Taming Technology. Information Age 
         Publishing, Inc: USA. 

Comments

  1. I love the look of your blog, it's simple and easy to read yet detailed. For a con, you stated: "Instructors mainly use podcasts and videos as full lecture recordings and fail to use them in more innovative, effective ways to promote learning". I found that this is a really nice way for learners to gather the information on their own time but definitely do agree that educators are missing out on all podcasts and video potential if they limit them to only recording full lectures. I think creativity can go a long way. I found it interesting how many different modes of technology were used for our last video/podcasting assignment. We all have our go-to technology resources or we tried a new mode for that project. Using new technology definitely takes time to learn but there are low to no cost options that would be great for those smaller schools you mentioned which have limited resources available.

    ReplyDelete
  2. That is an interesting point about the advantages (and disadvantages) that small schools have in integrating technology. I hadn't thought about the quicker decision process with fewer people involved. What advantages do K-12 or formal/informal adult education contexts have for technology integration? In my program, budget can be a limiting factor, but once we've funded a particular technology, there is still need to get instructors on board with training and convincing them of the benefits of the technology.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Wikis: Pros and Cons for Adult Learners

Wikis: Pros and Cons for Adult Learners Wikis are online platforms designed "to help groups collaborate, share, and build online content" (West & West, 2009). Wikis are meant to be a space where people can work asynchronously together on a common project. Wikis provide opportunities for team members working on a group project to each contribute to the design. Wikis are accessible by multiple people and anyone can contribute, edit, or remove content. (West & West, 2009). This is different from a blog where typically one person controls the content. Unlike discussion threads, the text in Wikis is not linked or linear, and can appear in varying formats on the wiki page (West & West, 2009). This can allow for more creativity and expression, but less structure if an instructor was wanting a particular template constructed for the Wiki. Warlick (as quoted in King and Cox, 2011), provided three advantages for working with Wikis: 1. Practical for ...

Blogging as a Learning Tool

Blogging as a Learning Tool According to the assigned readings for the week, blogging is a useful tool to facilitate learning. Kuo, et al. (2017) cite 4 reasons for this:  1. Students are actively participating and collaborating 2. Students are interacting and supporting each other 3. Students' motivation to learn is increased 4. Students develop critical thinking and reflective skills.  MacPhail (2019) and Witte (2007) both described examples of blogs as effective learning based on student engagement levels. In MacPhail's (2019) article she described how her students engaged "more closely with class materials" and thought "more deeply" about the subject (p. 3).  Witte (2007) described how her students were more engaged when writing for a blog than paper writing assignments. Her study paired preservice college teachers with middle school students and found that collaboration, participation, and supportive feedback were common when...